deepening.life
← All reads Grief & crisis

Falling Upward

Finding a Theological Framework Large Enough for Your Pain

By Bob4 min read

The Pain — A Faith Too Small for the Furnace

My journey with God has never followed a neat, conventional line.

From my earliest spiritual awakening to decades of navigating intense personal and relational trials, I often felt like an outsider in standard church culture. When deep crisis hit—when decades of marriage faced intense strain, or when I stood in the shadow of Jeanne’s passing—the simple, surface-level rules and formulas I had been taught felt completely inadequate.

Many believers hit a wall in the second half of life where their early theological frameworks simply collapse under the weight of real human suffering. We are taught that if we follow the rules, perform well, and maintain the right image, life will reward us with order and ease.

But when the storm comes anyway, you are left with an agonizing choice:

I couldn't go backward. I needed a truth deep enough to make sense of the furnace.

The Truth — Integrating the Wisdom of the Journey

In my personal seeking, God brought key voices into my life to help me decode what was happening in my soul.

First and foremost was Tom Paige, whose systematic teaching on Father’s grace, sovereign design, and the "Hand and Glove" completely reframed my understanding of God’s love. Tom showed me that human self-effort is a dead end, and that Father’s agape love is the only true source of life.

Alongside my time with Tom, I also spent years wrestling with the insights of authors like Franciscan friar Richard Rohr, particularly his work on Falling Upward and our movement from the False Self to the True Self.

While Tom was careful in his public ministry to keep the focus strictly anchored in core evangelical and scriptural foundations—understanding that traditional church culture can be wary of outside terminology—he privately understood the reality of this inner journey. For me personally, reading Rohr was like holding up a mirror to the exact spiritual furnace I was walking through.

What I came to realize in my own walk is that these insights do not replace core Scripture—they illuminate what the Apostles described all along:

  1. The First Half of Life (Building the Container): In our early years, we build our ego, our identity, our rules, and our boundaries (what Paul calls the "outer man" or the "flesh"). This container is necessary, but it is not the ultimate destination.
  2. The "Falling Upward" (The Necessary Suffering): Eventually, crisis, loss, or relational exhaustion cracks our ego container. It feels like defeat, but in God's economy, "falling" is the very process by which we fall into the arms of Father’s grace.
  3. The Second Half of Life (The True Self): As the False Self breaks, the "inner man" (the Spirit of Christ residing in your True Self) is renewed day by day (2 Corinthians 4:16).

This integration was my personal pathway to freedom. It allowed me to see that my grief and breaking were not signs that God had abandoned me, but signs that He was stripping away my false performance to reveal who He created me to be.

The Freedom — Walking Others Through the Furnace

Taking ownership of this personal journey brought profound peace. I no longer needed to defend my winding path, nor did I need to force every believer to read the exact same authors I read.

Truth is Truth, wherever Father uses it to light your path.

This brings us to the heart of what Tom Paige’s ReSouled ministry offers as a receiving sanctuary. While the ministry itself remains firmly grounded in the clear, accessible authority of Scripture and Father's grace, it provides a safe, mature harbor for those who are going through their own "second half of life" furnace.

In this sanctuary, leaders, counselors, and weary believers do not find rigid judgment or superficial answers. Instead, they find:

You do not have to fit into a shallow spiritual box to be loved by God. When your world falls apart, you aren't falling out of grace—you are simply falling upward into the inexhaustible, transforming hands of Abba Father.

Your next step

When it runs deeper than an article can carry, you don't have to carry it alone.

deepening.life is a quiet place to clear the noise, drop beneath the surface of performance-based living, and reorient yourself around who you already are in Christ. Take your time here. Read, breathe, and let these truths settle into your bones.

Sometimes reading isn't enough. ReSouled, a partner ministry we know and trust, offers counseling, small groups and retreats for people carrying burnout, grief and hard seasons. Take a one-minute check-in, and if ReSouled is a good fit for where you are, someone from their team will reach out.

Keep reading

StoryBob's story

Bob’s Story

The Journey from Performance to Rest in Him

Read Bob's story →
03Grief & crisis

Next Man Up

How Exposing the False Self Prepares You for Crisis

Read now →
09Grief & crisis

When the World Unravels

Grief, the Urn, and a Benevolent Father

Read now →
In crisis? Call or text 988